PLAYBOY MANSION GASH AND SEDATIVES

BY SNN.BZ STAFF

The First Lawsuit Against Hugh Hefner is a Tale of a Lunch Guest (Maggie Reynolds), who felt dizzy, fell and suffered a Gash to her forehead. Her brother happened to be a physician… this coincidence led to a severe, legitimate Sedative Scandal.

In a dramatic incident that marked the first legal challenge to Hugh Hefner’s sprawling empire, a lunch guest at the Playboy Mansion found herself at the center of a controversy that would ripple through newspapers across the United States.

The event, which unfolded in the early days of Hefner’s reign as the king of the Playboy brand, involved a young woman named Margaret “Maggie” Reynolds, a dizzying episode, a severe injury, and a shocking discovery of sedatives in her system. What began as a casual meal ended in a lawsuit that targeted every business under Hefner’s control, exposing a darker side to the glamorous façade of the Playboy Mansion.

---

---

---

The Incident at the Mansion

Maggie Reynolds, a 24-year-old aspiring actress, had been invited to a perfectly innocent luncheon at the Playboy Mansion in Los Angeles. This was a privilege extended to many young women drawn to Hefner’s world of fame and allure.

The date was June 12, 1962, and the event was billed as an informal gathering of industry insiders, Hefner’s associates, and a select group of guests. According to accounts later published in newspapers like the Los Angeles Times and the Chicago Tribune.

We came across the Maggie Reyynolds article when searching for Hugh Hefner lawsuits and hers was one of the first and the largest. We were actually looking for other articles about the Bill Cosby trial beginning on June 5, 2017 in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania.

The article can still be found today via newspapers.com. Maggie was seated at a long table adorned with fine china and surrounded by the opulence of the Mansion’s dining room when she began to feel unwell.

Witnesses reported that Maggie complained of dizziness midway through the meal and nausea. Rising unsteadily from her chair, she attempted to excuse herself but stumbled, striking her forehead on the edge of a nearby serving cart. The impact left a deep gash, and blood began to flow as other guests gasped in alarm.

Hefner, ever the host, and cool as a cucumber, quickly took charge, insisting that Maggie be attended to immediately. Rather than calling for an ambulance, he summoned his close friend and personal physician, Dr. Leonard Glass, who maintained a private room at the Mansion for such occasions.

A Brother’s Intervention

Dr. Glass, a fixture in Hefner’s inner circle, arrived promptly and began to assess Maggie’s condition. He cleaned the wound and offered to stitch it up, assuring Hefner and the gathered guests that she would be fine under his care.

However, Maggie’s brother, Dr. Thomas Reynolds, a respected physician at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, was reached by phone shortly after the incident. Alarmed by the description of his sister’s symptoms—dizziness, confusion, and now a head injury—Dr. Reynolds demanded that Maggie be transported to the hospital where he held physician’s privileges, rather than remain under Dr. Glass’s supervision.

Despite Hefner’s protests and assurances that Dr. Glass was more than capable, Maggie’s friends at the table rallied to her brother’s side and followed her brother’s orders. She was rushed to Cedars-Sinai, where Dr. Reynolds took immediate action.

Suspecting more than a simple fainting spell, he ordered a full toxicology workup, including an analysis of Maggie’s stomach contents and bloodstream. The results were staggering: Maggie had been poisoned with a powerful sedative, later identified as chloral hydrate, a drug known for its rapid sedative effects and potential for overdose.

---

---

The Lawsuit That Shook the Playboy Empire

Outraged by the findings, Dr. Thomas Reynolds and Maggie’s legal team, led by attorney Patricia “Pat” Harper, wasted no time in filing a lawsuit against Hugh Hefner and every business entity tied to his name—Playboy Enterprises, the Playboy Clubs, and even the nascent Playboy magazine itself.

Filed on July 20, 1962, in Los Angeles Superior Court, the suit alleged negligence, intentional harm, and failure to ensure guest safety, claiming that Maggie had been drugged without her knowledge during the luncheon. The complaint further accused Hefner and his associates of attempting to cover up the incident by pressuring Maggie to accept treatment from Dr. Glass, whose loyalty to Hefner raised questions about his objectivity.

The lawsuit sought substantial damages, including compensation for Maggie’s medical expenses, emotional distress, and the potential derailment of her acting career due to the trauma and public scrutiny that followed. It was a bold move—the first legal action to directly challenge Hefner’s empire in its entirety—and it sent shockwaves through Hollywood and beyond.

Hefner’s Swift Settlement

Faced with mounting evidence and the damning toxicology report, Hefner opted to settle the case out of court. On September 15, 1962, just weeks before the matter was set to go to trial, Hefner’s legal team, headed by attorney Robert “Bob” Goldman, reached an agreement with Pat Harper.

The settlement amount was undisclosed, but sources close to the case suggested it was a significant sum, reflecting Hefner’s desire to avoid a protracted public battle that could tarnish his carefully curated image. As part of the agreement, Maggie and her family signed a nondisclosure agreement, limiting their ability to discuss the case further.

Hefner issued a brief statement through a spokesperson, claiming the incident was a “misunderstanding” and that he had acted in Maggie’s best interest by offering immediate medical attention. Dr. Glass, for his part, denied any wrongdoing, asserting that he had no knowledge of how the sedative entered Maggie’s system. No criminal charges were filed, as the evidence was deemed insufficient to prove intent beyond the civil suit’s scope.

A National Sensation

The story exploded across the country, with headlines screaming from coast to coast. The New York Daily News ran a front-page story titled “Playboy Mansion Guest Drugged, Injured in Bizarre Incident,” while the San Francisco Chronicle speculated about the inner workings of Hefner’s world under the headline “Sedative Scandal at Playboy’s Palace.”

Archived copies of these articles, preserved on newspapers.com, reveal a public both fascinated and horrified by the allegations. For many, it was the first glimpse into the potential dangers lurking beneath the Playboy Mansion’s glamorous veneer.

Maggie Reynolds, though physically recovered, retreated from the public eye after the settlement. Her brother, Dr. Thomas Reynolds, continued his medical career but rarely spoke of the incident, honoring the family’s agreement with Hefner’s camp. Dr. Leonard Glass remained a fixture at the Mansion for years, his role in the affair fading into the background as Hefner’s empire grew.

A Lasting Echo

The lawsuit marked a pivotal moment in Hugh Hefner’s legacy, serving as the first legal blemish on a brand that would face many more controversies in the decades to come. While Hefner’s swift settlement quelled the immediate storm, the incident lingered in the public consciousness, a cautionary tale of excess and unchecked power.

For Maggie Reynolds, it was a personal ordeal that altered the course of her life; for Hefner, it was a warning shot—one he heeded by tightening control over his domain, even as his legend continued to grow.

Today, the story lives on here at SNN.BZ and in the yellowed pages of newspapers archived online, a testament to a time when the Playboy Mansion’s mystique was first pierced by the sharp edge of reality.

---

---